I don't need a lot of features. In fact, simpler is better. (Or at least easy to use without having to mess with a bunch of options.)
I am lazy. REALLY lazy. I realize there will be a learning curve, but the closer it is to a straight line, that's awesome.
One of my amps has a DI out and I have an interface which while probably not tonally ideal means I shouldn't have to use any amp models or cab sims unless I want to. (If you want a laugh, find my awful take on a drum jam where I don't have a cab sim running.

I have used Reaper. It was fine, way more than I need, but the price is right and if I was more patient I could probably learn the basics just fine.
Just looking for other options that I should maybe give a go.
Thanks!
Edit: I'm using Windows. I should've said that to begin with.
